My 4HB Goal: lose 70 lbs. 67 lbs down, 3 more to go.

    40

    questions

    226

    answers

    98

    helped

    Want to chat?

    I asked a question:
    1 day ago
    I commented on gretchenlin's reply:

    gretchenlin nailed it. Brazilian steakhouses are an SCD wonderland. The salad bar to start usually has some awesome veggies and salad. And then...

    2 days ago
    2 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Any Tips for Only a Small Gain on Treat Day?

    You will gain weight because eating carbs replenishes the glycogen that has been running low all week due to eating SCD. If you fast the day before, you will deplete them even further and you mig...

    2 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Changing cheat day for 1 week

    No problem. Enjoy your holiday and don't give it a second thought. Going to 5 days only becomes a problem if you are constantly doing a 5 day interval. That would mean you have an extra cheat d...

    2 days ago
    I asked a question:

    A nice video that explains why everyone responds differently to SCD

    I really liked this. Really hits home on how we are all different when it comes to weight loss or muscle building and the importance of tracking your data so you can figure out what works for you...

    3 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: SCD versus IF

    I vote for you to be our official 5:2 tester and report back. I tried 16/8 and didn't see any changes in weight loss but I kindof liked the skipping breakfast part and kindof didn't like stuffing...

    3 days ago
    I commented on G G's reply:

    shuko, 6kg in 8 weeks is outstanding. That's 1.65 lbs / week and that is a very good, sustainable rate. Lots of folks expect Tim's 20 lbs in 4 w...

    3 days ago
    I commented on G G's reply:

    koloryczerni, I just started maintenance this week, so I don't have any good data on what works or not yet. I'll provide updates as I go. This i...

    3 days ago
    I commented on G G's reply:

    I count calories using an app called MyFitnessPal. I used an online Total Daily Energy Expended (TDEE) calculator to determine how much I burn ev...

    3 days ago
    I commented on my reply:

    SCD is not very good for bulking unless you eat a LOT. It is tough to build muscle while in a caloric deficit. You can make some small gains as...

    3 days ago
    I commented on G G's reply:

    I lost 70 lbs on SCD. I only started counting calories when I stalled for 6 months at 205 lbs. turns out I was not eating enough so I ate more S...

    3 days ago
    I commented on G G's reply:

    I'm not sure. I have decided to maintain at 185 lbs and I am slowly increasing calories to do that. I have decided to add some non SCD foods to ...

    3 days ago
    I commented on my reply:

    I'll ask a question and then maybe change my answer: Why are you lifting? Are you lifting to build strength, muscle or both? Are you skinny and...

    6 days ago
    I commented on Dylan Tomlinson's reply:

    Good protein shakes have less sugar and carbs than a cup of broccoli.

    6 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Occam's protocol + swimming consecutively?

    Occom's is meant to put serious stress on your muscles and they react by growing. But if you are truely doing Occams, you should not be able to swim afterwards. 7 reps at a 5x5 cadence to comple...

    6 days ago
    I commented on my reply:

    Your data show no changes. At least as far as I can tell. You weigh 2 lbs less, but there isn't a body fat measuring device in the world that co...

    6 days ago
    I commented on my reply:

    Nothing in that chart would get me worried. All of those numbers are well within the error probability associated with bioimpedance measuring dev...

    6 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Help! Losing muscle mass, body fat keeps increasing

    How long have you been tracking your BF% on the scale? I track mine almost every day via multiple methods and I can gain or lose 2-3 lbs of muscle day to day. That clearly is not really the case...

    6 days ago
    I asked a question:

    Why we gain weight on cheat day

    Saw this on another forum and thought it might help folks not freak out so much on cheat day when they gain a lot of lbs. It's normal, and good for you. [BEGIN QUOTE] The reason most people th...

    6 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Hitting a plateau

    One week is not a plateau. It's a data point. Stick to SCD for another month and see what happens. I have had myriad one week pauses and many two weeks pauses, especially if I had a period of n...

    7 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: How long to to 4HB before break?

    Congrats on your progress so far. You are doing great. SCD for life, right? I would keep doing what you are doing and only change when you hit a stall. And a stall is staying at the same wei...

    7 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: 4 week check in

    Congrats! It looks like you are doing everything right and are set up for success. If you stall on weight, keep track of those inches. I would much rather lose inches than pounds.

    7 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Cheat day! :D

    Happy anniversary! Enjoy your day.

    7 days ago
    I commented on Amanda Ridding's reply:

    Richard, I am tomcornhole on MFP. Send me a friend request if you would like. Always nice to have SCD friends on there. It isn't very SCD frien...

    7 days ago
    I commented on Maria Rider's reply:

    I don't they are going to answer because the post was from last Nov. But it is a great topic.

    8 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Science behind 30in30 rule

    You already know what Tim says in the book with anecdotes and some limited sciency stuff. The only other studies I have seen on the topic relate only to eating breakfast vs. not eating breakfast....

    8 days ago
    I commented on Jeanette Eng's reply:

    There are a lot of thoughts on cheat day and different approaches. I have always cheated like crazy. The only thing I do now is make sure my lif...

    9 days ago
    I commented on Tanner Hoplock's reply:

    Follow the program and we an help you. Follow it 4 days a week and that is a different program.

    10 days ago
    I commented on my reply:

    I added magnesium to my to get list.

    10 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: 20 grams of protein per meal?

    The 20g is the weight of the protein inside something else. Not sure where you could find 20g of pure protein. I think they sell it at the GNC shops, but protein in a 3oz filet mignon is about 2...

    11 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Losing regularity

    Have you changed anything else besides food? Supplements really got me all buggered up from the exhaust standpoint. I was a 3x a day kinda guy before SCD. That went down to 2x a day when I firs...

    11 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Week One Complete!

    I was a sweetaholic. When I started SCD, I was going crazy. I was weak and almost failed completely. I immediately bought some Quest protein bars and scarfed those down (4 a day) to tackle the ...

    12 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Giving up artificial sweeteners

    I think it's a great experiment. I wish I had some data to help you out, but I don't. I started SCD drinking a LOT of diet coke (1.5L a day). I slowly weened myself off of it by week 12. I got...

    12 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Getting made fun of because of your diet?

    Don't get a lot of people making fun of my diet because they are mostly on it, too. But I did get a nice compliment from the neighbor gal yesterday. She said she was driving by and had to slow ...

    13 days ago
    I commented on G G's reply:

    Thanks G G. I am 72" tall.

    13 days ago
    I commented on Galia Knight's reply:

    That last part is probably the most important. Knowing an absolute accurate value for bf% is interesting in so far as you now have the number. B...

    14 days ago
    I commented on s joshua's reply:

    You can't eat too much. You'll find lots of articles on how too much will cause kidney failure. You'll find 10x articles on how it doesn't. For...

    14 days ago
    I commented on Travis Mitchell's reply:

    Any protein. It all counts.

    14 days ago
    14 days ago
    I commented on my reply:

    I have taken every supplement Tim has recommended at one point or another. Never found any of them to have an effect on my weight loss. Even PAG...

    16 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Why no exercise for the first 8-12 weeks?

    That's a great question. Tim explains it in the book but all over the book. The biggest point I just pulled out after re-reading the sections that talk about this: exercising can lead to reward...

    16 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Digestive enzymes: is it really must?

    I had the same thought a couple of weeks ago and even went so far as to order some probiotics off Amazon. They showed up last week and I haven't taken them. I really don't have any digestive is...

    16 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Had 4 glasses of wine last night

    wombat is correct. SCD is not meant to drive you nuts. Don't adjust anything to compensate. Just continue on and forget about it. This is a very important aspect of SCD and why it differs from...

    16 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: A newbie's numbers after Week 1!

    Excellent! Glad to here more good news from the 4HP crowd.

    16 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Safest way to increase calories?

    You are not getting enough calories and that is why you are not losing weight. Period, dot, end of story. People and doctors love Very Low Calorie (VLC) diets because they produce instant and us...

    16 days ago
    I commented on Maria Rider's reply:

    Thanks Akane. Definitely exciting times. I forgot to mention that my actual weight this morning was 184.7. My home scale is.9 lbs heavy but I h...

    16 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: Success Story

    Outstanding! I was hoping others would post success stories. More, more, more! We tend to get on technical runs on this forum sometimes and it's nice to get some feel good stuff popping up. So...

    16 days ago
    I replied to a question:

    Re: help with measurements

    The best way to find your actual waist is to bend to the side. The place that bends is your waist. This varies for everyone. And if you had a belly flap like I did, it will hang over your actua...

    16 days ago